LUMIX FZ1000 - FZ50   Tout sur :
Les LUMIX FZ 1000 - FZ50 et 30
Accueil FZ1000 | Liens | Contact | Livre d'Or
 DMC-FZ1000

Nouvelle partie du site consacrée au FZ1000


 FZ50 - et après ?

 FZ60 - "No future?"
 µ 4/3 - Le futur ?
 Lumix G1 - M4/3
 G1 vs FZ50
 La fin du FZ50


 FZ150

FZ150 Accueil FZ150
 FZ150 Vs FZ50
- ISO BdB

 FZ150 Vs FZ50
- Détails PDC et Zoom



 FZ50

FZ50 Accueil FZ50
 Le FZ50
 FZ50 - Réglages
 FZ50 - Le cours EZ
 FZ50 - Détails 1
 FZ50 - Détails 2
 FZ50 - ISO
 FZ50 - "Diaph"
 FZ50 - 35 mm
 FZ50 - Mac OS X
 FZ50 - Firmware
 FZ50 - Mpx / EZ ?
 FZ50 - Macro
 FZ50 - Retouches
 FZ50/FZ30 - Vidéo



 FZ30 et Maj FZ50

FZ30  Accueil FZ30
 Le FZ30
 Le "bruit" du FZ30 !
 Echec & Mat !
 EZ - Extended Zoom
 Balance des blancs
 [MODE DE MES.]
 Zoom sur ...
 FZ30 vs Kit reflex
 PDC & MAP
 Flash et EVF
 FZ30 pour les Nuls
 FZ50 et FZ30 - Lune
 Achat/Douanes
  SAV



 Galeries
FZ50 - FZ30


 Accessoires
FZ50 - FZ30

Accessoires FZ50 - FZ30 Bagues 55mm/xx
   Télé/Grand angle

 Filtres Photos
 Bonnettes macro
 Télécommandes
 Batt. - Grip FZ50
 Sd Card - Lecteurs
 Capuchons
   Pare-soleils

 Trépieds/Monopods
 Visées point rouge
 Flashs/Diffuseurs
 Housses & sacs
 Plongée - Housses
 Capuchon - balance
   des blancs



 Logiciels/Tutos

Logiciels / Tutos  RAW/SILKYPIX
   Camera RAW

 "Plug-Ins"
 Tutos/Utilitaires
 Exifs - Tuto
 Un "Pano" ?
 Balance des blancs


Mise en service
le 12/12/2005

Dernière(s) mise(s) à jour





25/01/2009
Balance des blancs
25/01/2009
Capuchon
Balance des blancs
25/01/2009
La fin du FZ50
22/02/2010
Carnaval de Venise 2010 14/06/2012
Batterie - Duracell
07/2012
Pano - Tête Velbon
08/2012
Paypal - Danger

 


 
FZ150 Vs FZ50 - Details 100 ISO & Dof Zoom
 
 
 

| Home Page (French) l | Home page FZ150 | FZ150 Vs FZ50 - ISO & Wb |
| Guestbook |

 

Home Page FZ150

FZ150 Vs FZ50 - ISO & White Balance

Home Page (French)


   Z150 Vs FZ50 - 100 ISO - 50 mm  
 
 


I had gone to a quick comparison between the FZ50 and FZ150.

So I installed a small scene in my living room, not at all "WAF" (Women Acceptance Factor), time to take some pictures and hop! Done.

Just two umbrellas and one softbox, to have a little light.

Already I could not make a similar white balance on both cameras, but also by watching the first pictures, I thought they sold me an FZ100 instead of an FZ150. 

So I changed my scene, repeated the tests...
After a few days ...
Miss Nemo ... What are you doing? You've long?
No, no... I check something...  Waf! Waf!

The FZ150 is not as homogeneous as the FZ50, as I have a reputation of fundamentalist FZ50, I told myself there, they will not believe me.
So some "crops" comparisons quickly, it did not do so.

Finally I reached the following...

 All photos are free and you can do what you want without my consent.
If you want all the pictures and/or RAW files, simply contact me and I will send you a temporary link to download.
Photos 255 Mb and RAW 323 Mb in .zip file.

 Before continuing, we must understand that this type of exercise, if it's interesting to compare the FZ50 five years old with a recent FZ150, has no sense in real life photographic.
Images in their normal size, show no failure visible at over 100%.
So do not worry, you can buy my own (like new), I put on sale, now that I finished my comparison.
If I sell it, only because I do not support motorized zoom.
You will make fantastic photos ... I ask you to believe me!  

 
 FZ150 Vs FZ50 - f/3.2 - f/8  
 
 


FZ150 12 Mpx - FZ50 10 Mpx

FZ150 (2011) - Lens : 4.5 - 108 mm (25 - 600 mm) - Sensor MOS 1/2.33
FZ50 (2006) - Lens : 7.7 - 88.8 mm (35 - 420 mm) - Sensor CCD 1/1.7

So to compare the two cameras, I chose the 50 mm focal length ISO 100 with an aperture that start at f/3.2 to f/8 (maximum FZ150).

The original size photos are available in Smugmug.

Click to enlarge!

f/3.2
FZ150 - f/3.2
FZ150
49 mm - 1/100e
f/4.5
FZ150 - f/4.5
FZ150
49 mm - 1/50e
f/5.6
FZ150 - f/5.6
FZ150
49 mm - 1/30e
f/8
FZ150 - f/8
FZ150
49 mm - 1/15e
f/3.2
FZ50 - f/3.2
FZ50
50 mm -1/100e
f/4.5
FZ50 - f/4.5
FZ50
50 mm - 1/50e
f/5.6
FZ50 - f/5.6
FZ50
50 mm - 1/30e
f/8
FZ50 - f/8
FZ50
50 mm - 1/13e

 

 

Top of page

 

 
 FZ150 Vs FZ50  
 




Crop 1 - Bottom
f/3.2
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/3.2 - Bottom
FZ150 - FZ50
f/4.5
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/4.5 - Bottom
FZ150 - FZ50
f/5.6
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/5.6 - Bottom
FZ150 - FZ50
f/8
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/8 - Bottom
FZ150 - FZ50

Click "f/3.2" ... Ouch!    It starts badly for the FZ150, with a big difference in sharpness compared to the FZ50.
Up to f/5.6 the FZ50 is normal, for the FZ150 there is a slight improvement.
At f/8 sharpness is not as good for the FZ50, but still better than the FZ150.

The FZ150 shows a loss of sharpness in image bottom with an improvement by going to the image right.

FZ150 chromatic aberrations is limited in the normal size image, but they are treated worse by the FZ150 internal software.
In RAW, the two cameras seem to have the same level of chromatic aberration, but the FZ150 jpeg treatment is worse compared to the FZ50.
Again, this is far from catastrophic, but compared to my FZ50 to me that love, is not so good.

Optical/Sensor stress or preferential treatment of Panasonic for its new bridges generation, no one will ever know.
Perhaps they have lost the software sources that processes the CA?

 

 

Crop 2 - Bottom
f/3.2
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/3.2 - Bottom
FZ150 - FZ50
f/4.5
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/4.5 - Bottom
FZ150 - FZ50
f/5.6
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/5.6 - Bottom
FZ150 - FZ50
f/8
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/8 - Bottom
FZ150 - FZ50

Bottom left to the center , there is always this difference in sharpness.

 

Crop 3 - Bottom
f/3.2
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/3.2 - Bottom
FZ150 - FZ50
f/4.5
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/4.5 - Bottom
FZ150 - FZ50
f/5.6
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/5.6 - Bottom
FZ150 - FZ50
f/8
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/8 - Bottom
FZ150 - FZ50


Crop 4 - Bottom

f/3.2
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/3.2 - Bottom
FZ150 - FZ50
f/4.5
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/4.5 - Bottom
FZ150 - FZ50
f/5.6
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/5.6 - Bottom
FZ150 - FZ50
f/8
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/8 - Bottom
FZ150 - FZ50

The matchboxes bottom center, still show a difference in sharpness.

 

Crop 5 - Bottom
f/3.2
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/3.2 - Bottom
FZ150 - FZ50
f/4.5
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/4.5 - Bottom
FZ150 - FZ50
f/5.6
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/5.6 - Bottom
FZ150 - FZ50
f/8
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/8 - Bottom
FZ150 - FZ50

Further to the right at the statue is a bit better for the FZ150..

 

Crop 6 - Bottom
f/3.2
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/3.2 - Bottom
FZ150 - FZ50
f/4.5
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/4.5 - Bottom
FZ150 - FZ50
f/5.6
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/5.6 - Bottom
FZ150 - FZ50
f/8
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/8 - Bottom
FZ150 - FZ50

At the Green book, at f/3.2 and f/4.5 is much better for the FZ150, almost equivalent to the FZ50. At f/5.6 it is also equal, but not to f/8.

 

Crop 7-Bottom
f/3.2
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/3.2 - Bottom
FZ150 - FZ50
f/4.5
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/4.5 - Bottom
FZ150 - FZ50
f/5.6
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/4.5 - Bottom
FZ150 - FZ50
f/8
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/4.5 - Bottom
FZ150 - FZ50

image bottom right, f/3.2 to f/5.6 are very close.
Always a little worse for the FZ150 at f/8.

 

 

Crop 8 - Center
f/3.2
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/3.2 - Center
FZ150 - FZ50
f/4.5
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/4.5 - Center
FZ150 - FZ50
f/5.6
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/5.6 - Center
FZ150 - FZ50
f/8
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/8 - Center
FZ150 - FZ50

Crop 9 - Center
f/3.2
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/3.2 - Center
FZ150 - FZ50
f/4.5
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/4.5 - Center
FZ150 - FZ50
f/5.6
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/5.6 - Center
FZ150 - FZ50
f/8
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/8 - Center
FZ150 - FZ50
Crop 10 - Center
f/3.2
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/3.2 - Center
FZ150 - FZ50
f/4.5
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/4.5 - Center
FZ150 - FZ50
f/5.6
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/5.6 - Center
FZ150 - FZ50
f/8
FZ150 vs FZ50 - f/8 - Center
FZ150 - FZ50

In the center is very similar to f/3.2 - f/5.6, the FZ150 might be a little better. At f/8 there is always a small loss sharpness for both cameras, but a little stronger on the FZ150.

 

 

Crop 11 - Up
f/3.2

FZ150 - FZ50
f/4.5

FZ150 - FZ50
f/5.6

FZ150 - FZ50
f/8

FZ150 - FZ50

On top, no particular problem of f/3.2 - f/5.6. A little more color noise in the highlights for the FZ150 and a little more in dark areas for the FZ50. Is negligible for a full size image.

 

Top of page

 
 


   Z150 VS FZ50 - DoF & Zoom  
 
 


To compare the level of zoom and DoF (Depth of Field), I put the settings in "normal" and "A" (Aperture).
I set the exposure as for me ... less 1/3 EV for the FZ150 and less 2/3 EV for the FZ50.

On tripod.


 
 FZ150 Vs FZ50 - 420 mm  
 
 

 

f/4.3 - 424 mm
FZ150 - f/4.3 - 424 mm
FZ150
1/500e - -1/3 EV

f/3.7 - 420 mm
FZ50 - f/3.7 - 420 mm
FZ50
1/800e - -2/3 EV

 

f/8 - 424 mm
FZ150 - f/8 - 424 mm
FZ150
1/160e - -1/3 EV
f/11 - 420 mm
FZ50 - f/11 - 420 mm
FZ50
1/100e - -2/3 EV

 

424 - 420 mm
f/4.3 - f/3.7
FZ150 Vs FZ50 - 420 mm
FZ150 - FZ50
424 - 420 mm
f/8 - f/11
FZ150 Vs FZ50 - 420 mm
FZ150 - FZ50

FZ150 424 mm f/4.3 against f/3.7 for the FZ50 which displays a higher speed.
The DoF is slightly lower for the FZ150.

To 420 with a smaller aperture f/8 and f/11. Logically, the FZ50 which closes at f/11 shows a somewhat larger DoF.

 

 

Top of page

 

 
 FZ150 Vs FZ50 - 600 mm  
 


 

600 mm
f/5.2
FZ150 - f/5.2 - 600 mm
FZ150
1/500 - -1/3 EV
600 mm
f/8
FZ150 - f/8 - 600 mm
FZ150
1/250 - -1/3 EV

 

600 - 420 mm
f/5.2 - f/3.7
FZ150 Vs FZ50 - 600 mm
FZ150 - FZ50
600 - 420 mm
f/8 - f/11
FZ150 Vs FZ50 - 600 mm
FZ150 - FZ50

However, the FZ150 grows to 600 mm and there, the DoF is compensated by the power Zoom. To f/5.2 against f/3.7 it is equal with impressive image quality that outperforms the FZ50 dropped with 420 mm.

When we close, the picture quality is still there, but the f/8 DoF is shorter than f/11 reinforced by a longer focal length, which is logical.

 

Top of page

 
 


   Z150 VS FZ50 - Conclusion  
 
 


The FZ50 is not completely obsolete. With a smaller sensor and more 2 Megapixel, the FZ150 is "almost" equal to the FZ50. 620 mm from the FZ150 offers more opportunity with excellent image quality.

The problem of sharpness in the bottom of the image at 50 mm, is spectacular but relatively anecdotal. From wide angle to 50/60 mm it will be virtually invisible on the picture.

The FZ150 loses a little sharpness by closing up to f/8, but that's normal, it is also the case with the FZ50. The FZ50 closes at f/11 which gives it a little field.
At f/8 the FZ50 is better than the FZ150.

In addition, the FZ150 is a little better in noise reduction, less than anticipated in the test of the black cap, but a good one f-stop anyway.

Given the fact that it closes (f/5.2), you may need up to 200 ISO when the FZ50 will be even at ISO 100. We can go up to ISO 600 without too much trouble, beyond it becomes really difficult.

I also watched the stabilizer at 420 mm the FZ50 allows sharp pictures at 1/20 with 80% success rate if it is held firmly. With the FZ150 it will not fall below 1/30 of the max zoom lens (600 mm).
The stabilizer is still effective.
At least one stable thing in Pana in six years!  

Finally, menus and functions are quite well thought out with much more possibilities than the FZ50, RAW and JPEG, fine settings, Larger LCD screen and better articulated, HD video and more.

It is regrettable for the EVF still not HD..

In any logical, the FZ150 should be in place of the FZ45 with a real expert bridge in place of the FZ150.

But the logic of Panasonic has its reasons, which reason does not know.  

 

 

 

Home Page FZ150

FZ150 Vs FZ50 - ISO & White Balance

Home Page (French)

 

The older resist!

 

Haut de page